Thursday, 15 September 2011

Treatment of Karachi Syndrome

The demography of Karachi is 25% Urdu Speaking Hindustani Muhajir population, 15% Punjabi, 15% Pathan, 10% Sindhi, 10% Gujrati, 10% Rajisthani, 5% Baloch and 10% Others.

25% Urdu Speaking Hindustani Muhajir population is politically affiliated with the MQM.

15% Pathan population is politically affiliated with the ANP.

10% Sindhi and 5% Baloch population is politically affiliated with the PPP.

15% Punjabi, 10% Gujrati, 10% Rajisthani and 10% Others are not proactive in the politics of Karachi.

However, for the peace in Karachi;

1. Military Administrative action by consent of P.P.P, M.Q.M and A.N.P. The result will be long-term peace in Karachi.
  
2. Military Administrative action without consent of P.P.P, M.Q.M or A.N.P. The result will be long-term hate with the Military and Punjab in Karachi.
  
3. Paramilitary Administrative action, after imposing “Governor Rule with Neutral Cabinet” admissible to Sindhi, Muhajir and Pukhtoon masses of Sindh. The result will be long-term peace in Karachi.

 4. Civil war between Muhajir v/s Pukhtoon, Muhajir v/s Baloch and Muhajir v/s Sindhis in Karachi and Sindhi V/s Muhajir in Hyderabad, Sukkur, Nawabshah and Mirpurkhas. The result will be to choose any one (1) option from above.
  
Memorandum;
  
It is also possible that due to delay in decision to solve the Karachi problem, the Sindh game may go into the hands of Non-PPP Players i.e. Sindhi Nationalists and other Sindhi Politicians.
  
According to the constitution, the military is supposed to perform under the charter of duties and according to the law.

Law and order is a provincial subject, without the request of Provincial government even the federal government is not authorized to order the military to interfere in provincial subjects.

Therefore, Military Administrative action by consent of P.P.P, M.Q.M, and A.N.P, and after the approval of the provincial government will result the long-term peace in Karachi.

Otherwise, Military Administrative action without consent of P.P.P, M.Q.M and A.N.P and without approval of the provincial government will be illegal if directed by the federal government or it will be unconstitutional, if declared by military own self, it will result the long-term hate against Military, Punjab, Punjabis and Karachi will be the  Booby Trap for Military.
  
Therefore, in the current scenario the Paramilitary Administrative action, after imposing “Governor Rule with Neutral Cabinet” admissible to Sindhi, Muhajir and Pukhtoon masses of Sindh is a possible solution. It will result the long-term peace in Karachi.
  
Otherwise prevailing social and political trends of Karachi and Sindh will lead the situation towards the civil war between Muhajir v/s Pukhtoon, Muhajir v/s Baloch and Muhajir v/s Sindhis in Karachi and Sindhi V/s Muhajir in Hyderabad, Sukkur, Nawabshah and Mirpurkhas.

However, in the end of civil war, again the solution will be to choose any one (1) option from above. Then why not to choose any one option right now?
  
Anyhow, these options are still long term but not permanent solution.
  
For permanent peace in Karachi, intellectual, social, political, administrative and economical honesty and justice is a vital factor by all the ethnic communities of Karachi.
  
Trend to praise, cooperate, save and support the evils of own community and to criticize, confront, dominate and discourage the rights of other community will make the atmosphere, even for military, impossible to treat the syndrome of Karachi.
  
Wise says:

First trace the cause of Problem then treats the problem. Therefore, what is the primary, basic and initial cause of Karachi Syndrome?

1. Intellectual Dishonesty by the writers, journalists and scholar?

2. Social Hate between ethnic communities Muhajir, Sindhi, Baloch, Pathan, Punjabi?

3. War of Economical Domination between Muhajir, Sindhi, Baloch, Pathan, Punjabi?

4. War of Political Revenge between M.Q.M, A.N.P, P.P.P Political leaders, supporters and workers?

5. Struggle of Administrative Domination by the M.Q.M, A.N.P, P.P.P Political leaders, supporters and workers or by the Muhajir, Sindhi, Baloch, Pathan, Punjabi communities?

To avoid the reality, indicates the unwillingness, to solve the problem by honor, justice and dignity.